Does the insurance company pay replacement cost if I don't replace
my property?

If you have replacement cost coverage, in order to receive the replacement value insurance policies
require that you replace the property in question.  At first glance this may seem unfair, but with a
complete understanding of the rationale, it should make good sense to anyone.  

One of the most basic principals of insurance is to return a customer to the same financial condition
they were in before they suffered the loss.  Many times the replacement cost of property is greater
than the actual value of that item - such as a 15 year old 30" TV.  A new 30" TV might cost $500.  
But if you tried to sell the old one, you might only fetch $100.  Generally replacement won't be
required for claims under $2,000 to get the full replacement value.  But for larger claims, you will
have to replace the property in order to receive replacement value.  Consider a home for example.  
A brand new a home might cost $350,000 to build (excluding the land), but a home that is 30 years
old and in used condition and may only fetch $275,000 (including the land) if sold on the open
market.  In this situation, the insured person would be financially better off if the house were to burn
to the ground - assuming they received full replacement value without having to rebuild.  They
certainly couldn't have sold it for more than the $275,000 market value.

The traditional problem with an insured being potentially enriched is that there exists less incentive to
protect one's property from loss.  This in turn would result in more claims, and for higher property
rates.  In the end, it doesn't serve the best interest of the general public.





These explanations are intended to provide a simple understanding of some of the basic provisions
found in most insurance policies.  Sometimes simple explanations do not address all of the particular
circumstances of a claim, nor may they take into consideration case law or other provisions within a
policy.  This FAQ section of the website does not replace, alter or amend any language in your policy,
its terms, conditions or exclusions.  
1700 E BELTLINE AVE NE, SUITE 120, GRAND RAPIDS, MI 49525-7044
_Frequent Questions

Automobile
What is the Michigan
Catastrophic Claims
Association (MCCA)?

Bills
Why is it important to pay
my bill on time?

Claims
What if I don't replace my
property, does the
insurance company still pay
replacement cost?

Should I have my car
windshield repaired or
replaced?

What do I have to do to
have my claim paid?  What
are my responsibilities
during a claim?

General
Why do insurance
companies use insurance
score discounts?  Is it fair?

Property
Why is my replacement cost
more than my home or
building is worth?